Recipe – Baked Stuffed Shrimp – A Fine New Year’s Eve Dinner

Hi Friends!  Welcome!

Mr. Hungry and I are still hemming and hawing about what to cook for dinner…both for New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day.  I swear it’s one of our favorite past times – figuring out what to cook next together.  Truly.

As I was making up a pan of Baked Stuffed Shrimp for our traditional Christmas dinner, I thought you might like to know how we make it in our house.  Every year we wonder why we don’t make it more often. It’s certainly not difficult.  Not with shrimp available de-veined and ready to go.

Family Favorite Baked Stuffed Shrimp

One Shrimp

Don’t you want to pop that right in your mouth?

I like to use nice big shrimp – in this instance I used (frozen, uncooked, de-veined) shrimp that were 8-12 count per pound.  They came in a 2 lb. bag so I made a double recipe.  Defrost them in the refrigerator or in a bowl of cold water set in the sink.  Let the faucet trickle cool water on them for several minutes. Blot them dry.

Shrimp Raw

If this is your only entrée I’d figure 3-4 shrimp per person (at that big size) depending on what you serve with it.  On Christmas, our tradition is to serve both Prime Rib and Baked Stuffed Shrimp, in which case people only eat a couple per person at most.  If you use a higher count shrimp (per pound), just adjust for more shrimp per person.

There’s nothing magical and fantastical about the ingredients here.  It’s the combination that comes together to make the best traditional Baked Stuffed Shrimp I’ve ever had anywhere.  Aside from the shrimp itself, it starts with three main ingredients.

Ritz Crackers, Crab Meat and Butter

Come on now…tell me you haven’t eaten a whole sleeve of Ritz crackers at least once in your life.  They’re the Best for making buttery crumbly toppings and stuffings.  I almost always have a box in the pantry.  I crush them up in a gallon Ziploc bag using a rolling pin (hands work fine too).  Since shrimp sizes vary and number of servings vary based on your guest list, just think of it as 2-3 crackers per piece of shrimp.  It’s not an exact science.

I typically buy fresh canned crab meat, found in the refrigerator case next to the seafood counter.  You certainly can use the small cans of crab found near the tuna fish too, but the fresh is…well fresher.  It usually comes in 2 or 3 different grades.  The claw meat is the least expensive and works just fine for stuffing.  I save the Colossal for times when you want nice BIG chunks of crab (like making Crab Rolls with melted butter – in place of lobster-mmm).  Here’s one type of fresh crab:

Crabmeat in a can

Baked Stuffed Shrimp:

1 lb. of Shrimp – As I said earlier I used the 8-12 count per lb (use smaller  & don’t cook it quite so long) peeled, de-veined and split down the tail nearly all the way through so that they’re butterflied open to hold the stuffing

1 sleeve of Ritz Crackers, crushed fairly fine

1/2 c. Butter, melted

8 oz. Crab Meat

1 small onion, minced and sautéed till golden in a little butter

2 T. chopped Fresh Dill Weed (or 1 tsp. dried) – optional for you but not for me

Salt and Pepper to taste

Shrimp Stuffing IngredientsCombine crushed crackers, melted butter, crab meat, minced onion, dill and salt & pepper in a bowl.  Just mix it lightly.  Try not to break up the crab too much.

Shrimp Stuffing in Bowl

Preheat the oven to 375 degrees.

You’ll be putting the shrimp into a greased serving dish (I like to use a nice dish you’d be proud to put on the table.  I’m actually a little obsessive about that even when it’s just me & the Mr.) and use a size that will fit the shrimp snugly so that they hold each other up.

Take some stuffing in your hands & form it into a bit of an egg shape & place on top of each of the shrimp.  Place them in the pan with the tails up.

Shrimp Stuffing in Hands

Shrimp Ready for Baking

Bake at 375 degrees for a mere 20 minutes.  That’s it.  Quick right?  Shrimp don’t take long at all.

And there you go…a special treat fit for New Years Eve or any night for that matter.  When you break it down, it’s not an overly expensive treat.  I figure it costs less than $2. per shrimp, so do the math.  It’s a whole lot cheaper than going out & way better too.

Now, for a few ideas on variation.  I always use dill weed, but you could eliminate it and add fresh chopped parsley instead.  Some people add minced celery or fresh garlic sautéed along with the onion.  Add a few tablespoons of white wine or Vermouth to the dish if you’d like.  Add chopped clams or scallops to the stuffing too.  Some like to serve them with a little melted butter for dipping on the side, although there’s PLENTY of butter in them already (even for Mrs. Butterton). Serve with fresh lemon wedges to squeeze over the top if you want to brighten it up.

Family Favorite Baked Stuffed Shrimp

So there you have an entrée fit for Christmas Dinner or New Year’s Eve, yet easy enough for any special dinner party or Tuesday night supper.

So long for now.  I’ve got to figure out what I’m cooking for the holiday.

Ya got any ideas for me?

Wishing all of you a delicious New Year’s!

love, donna

3 thoughts on “Recipe – Baked Stuffed Shrimp – A Fine New Year’s Eve Dinner

  1. Marvelous, Donna! And I do agree – Ritz crackers or nothing! The only variation I use is a little bit of finely chopped red bell pepper – it’s so good with seafood. I don’t use onion but can certainly see how it makes it yummy. Simple is the key methinks! And shhhh, I usually sneak in a shake or two of some cayenne pepper, and I do give a little “anointing” of lemon juice on the shrimpies before stuffing. This stuffing works really well with Tilapia too – whether rolled or mounded up on top of the fish. Ok, I really am hungry now! Love you! Happy New Year!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s